What are the best Zelda games? Following decades of adventures across Nintendo consoles, ranking The Legend of Zelda series is one heck of an undertaking. Most stand among the very best games on their respective consoles, so assembling a ranked Zelda list is no small task.
We've compiled this list of the best Zelda games to help you sort the Hyrules from the Lorules. It includes every mainline game, Zelda remasters and remakes, and significant spin-offs.
So, let's grab the Master Sword and our Hylian Shield and head out on an adventure. Here is the Legend of Zelda series ranked from worst to best.
An introduction to the little-used plastic Wii Zapper peripheral, Link's Crossbow Training is a little nine-level high-score shooting game which uses various assets and areas from Twilight Princess as Link attempts to improve his crossbow skills using the Wii Remote's pointer functionality.
It's not unenjoyable, and you can pick the disc up for next to nothing these days. While there are sections where you can control Link in a first/third-person perspective, it should not be confused with a fully-fledged Zelda game in any way, shape or form. It is, however, a fun little aside in the Legend of Zelda-verse.
One of several multiplayer-focued Zeldas, Tri Force Heroes, while not a bad game, pales in comparison to other series entries (and the Four Swords games in particular).
You play as Blue, Green, and Red Link, and work together to battle bosses, solve puzzles, and gather loot. The big new feature was the Totem mechanic, which enabled you to stack the three Links on top of each other, although it just wasn't enough to elevate this entry.
Tri Force Heroes still exudes the charm of the franchise and throws in some delightful features all of its own. Outfits are a high point, as are the presentation and soundtrack, and there are moments of wonder when level design and teamwork come together in harmony.
However, uneven stage design, poor communication options, and a single-player experience that feels like an afterthought put this one at the bottom of the illustrious series' Totem pole.
A radical departure from the original and arguably the most difficult game in the series, Zelda II has enjoyed something of a reappraisal in recent, post-Dark Souls years.
In a series that, in the past, risked becoming by-the-numbers by slavishly sticking to a formula, this first sequel was anything but a repetition. A deeper combat system with RPG levelling elements and side-on platforming villages and dungeons made this a very different take on the Zelda template.
You could argue that too much of its sense of adventure and 'wonder' is lost to frustration, but no more so than in other challenging 8-bit games. If you find the challenge too much to bear, the rewind function in the Nintendo Switch Online version comes in useful. If you've bounced off The Adventure of Link in the past, we'd urge you to give it another go.
The first Four Swords experience — originally an 'add-on' mode included as part of the GBA port of Link to the Past — was multiplayer-only until an enhanced port added a single-player mode and was made available on DSiWare for free for a limited time in 2011 (and later very briefly on 3DS in 2014).
It enabled up to four friends to battle through Hyrule together as four Links in differently coloured garb and is very good, too. If you can find it.
Long answer: Brace Yourself Games didn't simply swap out Crypt of the NecroDancer's sprites with Link and Zelda. This musical, roguelite take on Hyrule delivers everything you'd expect: the exploration, discovery, wonder, items, dungeons, and — most of all — music, all shot through with a rhythm-based gameplay twist that takes a while to get used to but is immensely satisfying once mastered.
This would be a great Zelda game if you've played all the others to death; it's the most replayable entry, with each new run juggling the landscape and layout of the kingdom (cleverly playing with the notion of Hyrule's ever-changing geography throughout the series), meaning no playthrough will be quite the same.
It won't click with everyone, and if you're after 80-hour epics, look elsewhere. But there are plenty of those already. Having a smaller Hylian experience that feels uniquely fresh and also completely 'Zelda' is a joy.
Starring 'Toon Link' from The Wind Waker, Phantom Hourglass made great use of the touchscreen and, combined with the layout, structure, and design typical of the Zelda franchise, made this a familiar yet fresh entry.
If you missed Phantom Hourglass, don't listen to the naysayers — this is a wonderful little experience that's still worth hunting down.
A collaborative adventure in the Legend of Zelda mould was something many had dreamt of for a long time, and the Four Swords part of the GBA port of A Link to the Past made the jump to the TV screen here in Four Swords Adventures.
There's a single-player game in there, but the real meat of the experience involved four players hooking their own GBA to a GameCube with the requisite link cable and controlling their Link in a screen-hopping adventure long before Nintendo went asymmetric with the Wii U gamepad.
It's a brilliant co-op Zelda game hampered only by the fact that it required so much kit to function.
There we have it – all the Legend of Zelda games ranked.
Best Zelda FAQ
Nice work getting through all those adventures. Let's finish with a little post-quest Q&A where we answer the common questions readers have about the Zelda games.
What was the first Zelda game?
The Zelda series began with The Legend of Zelda, released in February 1986 in Japan, August 1987 in North America, and November 1987 in Europe.
While the game launched for NES overseas, the original Japanese version debuted on the Famicom Disk System, a disc-based add-on console for the Famicom that only launched in Japan.
It wasn't until 1994 that The Legend of Zelda appeared on a Famicom cartridge in Nintendo's homeland.
How many Zelda games are there?
There are 28 Zelda games in the mainline series, including colour/HD remasters and 3D remakes.
That's counting the Oracles games as separate titles, and includes multiplayer-focused Zeldas such as Four Swords, Four Swords Adventures, and Tri Force Heroes, although there's debate among fans over whether they are truly 'mainline' entries. We'll leave that up to you to decide!
What's the latest Zelda game?
The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom is the most recent game in the series. It launched on Thursday 26th September 2024.
Which Zelda game should I start with?
Zelda: A Link to the Past for Super NES is a good starting point. We asked Nintendo Life readers and that's what they chose.
LTTP took the outline of the original game and solidified it into an overworld-dungeon template that formed the basis for the entire series. It's available to play on Switch with a Nintendo Switch Online subscription.
Ocarina of Time is another must-play — the first 3D game in the Zelda series. On Switch, Breath of the Wild is considered an excellent first Zelda game.
Comments 204
Link Between Worlds should be in the top 5, but solid list.
Majora's Mask (N64) is the best. I felt that way when it released, and I feel that way even more now after it has been followed up by many great but inferior Zelda games.
Cadence of Hyrule should be higher
Didn't we already have one of these? Well thanks for the new one! Now this wonderful comment will sit near the top of the list for everyone to see FOR ALL TIME.
No Zelda's Adventure ?!? What a lousy list.
BOTW is my favorite game by far and the only game that can top it is TOTK
Ha, this is stupid, N64 Majora's Mask isn't even on the list!
Edit: now it is.
No Oracle of Ages or Seasons? Onyx didn't die for this level of disrespect.
I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again: Breath Of The Wild has earned its place. Ocarina of time is phenomenal, but Breath Of The Wild is literally Ocarina but bigger and better looking, minus the ganondorf.
I too think that BotW is just a modern gaming marvel!
@TheBigBlue BotW is great but it doesn't have dozens of memorable moments like OoT, does it? I've completed BotW 4 times and almost nothing stands out in my mind. It's a fun exploratory experience for sure, but everything kind of blend together with the open world. The Lost Woods, Hyrule Castle, and Divine Beasts are the only memorable parts. Whereas in OoT, nearly every area, character, song, cut scene, dungeon, and boss is engraved in my mind.
That said, I probably do prefer BotW, but I would never say that it's "literally Ocarina but bigger." The experiences are quite vastly different, and without the fact that they both feature Link, I don't think most people would objectively find the games all that similar at all.
Disagree about BOTW, but eh.
@IceCatraz @Strumpan A tagging mishap — they're all present now.
Link's Awakening DX, A Link to the Past, Majora's Mask, Four Sword Adventures and BotW are my favorites and in that order. Most Zelda games are amazing but these are the ones I play time and again. When will they give us a Paper Zelda game???
Minish Cap deserves to be in the top 10. Skyward Sword deserves to be in the bottom 2.
Nothing makes me more tempted to believe the average person has objectively awful taste than seeing Breath of the Wild, Link to the Past, and Wind Waker in the top 5 while Twilight Princess barely makes 10 and Skyward Sword doesn't even make 20.
My favourite is Twilight Princess and Breath of the Wild is seriously overrated, but that's just my opinion, clearly a majority thinks differently.
They all great and gave us hours of fun.
The top 10 can be in any order
Not gonna lie, it's a little odd seeing the remastered versions ranked lower than the original games.
@dartmonkey The incredible Link’s Awakening Switch remake is absent!
Now… let’s all vote it into the top 10!
I definitely wouldn't rank Skyward Sword that low myself, but I know how divisive that game was.
Ok I was looking at where the Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland was and while scrolling I was "ok, not the last... wait it made it to top 20? TOP 10?" All that emotional rollercoaster only to see that it's not on the list at all.
@somnambulance It ain’t now. 😉 Thanks 👍
No Hyrule Warriors Age of Calamity?
@NintendoByNature
I think it comes down how it was at the time it was released. Sure, the remakes are still great games, but they don't have the same impact as when the originals were released.
For instance, OoT on N64 has blurryness in distances and short draw distances, making it visually a much more mysterious game than later releases, and it subtracts a lot from it, personally.
@Strumpan Yes it is…?
I agree… even though the Tingle duology aren’t technically a Zelda game… they should be considered.
Also Age of Calamity is missing.
And … sigh … BOTW shouldn’t even be in the top 3-5 ….. I think many people see through all the wrongs of that game as time passes by
Twilight Ptincess is the most disrespected Zelda title, while Wind Waker is the most overrated.
Link To The Past is still the best Zelda game made, I'm surprised Nintendo hasn't made a 3D remake of it.
@marandahir Now it is. It wasn't at first.
Fascinating that the only remakes in the top ten are Ocarina of Time 3D at No. 7 and The Wind Waker HD at no. 6.
These were the only remakes that were pretty much universally loved, to my recollection, and they both felt like substantial improvements on their predecessors akin to that of Metroid Prime Remastered or Xenoblade Chronicles Definitive Edition that they are THE definitive way to play the game.
While I loved the TPHD, SSHD, LADX, LAHD, HWL, HWDE, and MM3D remakes, I understand where each of those get criticized.
TPHD had the amiibo-locked hard mode and bonus dungeons. I had the amiibo, but I get the complaint. It also was less of an improvement on TP than WWHD was on TWW.
MM3D may be an improvement in nearly every way on MM - save perhaps the boss fights, the location of the Stone Mask and Giant's Mask, the Zora swimming, and the change in tone when you're not personally scared about losing your progress now that you can perma-save at anytime or even just close the 3DS to put the game to sleep. I personally prefer 100% of the changes in the game, but I get the complaints.
SSHD and the Hyrule Warrior remakes are only listed above because their base titles are considered "not good enough" to make the top ten. I loved them, though.
Link's Awakening's 2 remakes — I'm surprised neither made the top ten, but not surprised that the original GB version is #3 on the list. There's something about the originality of the first version of the game that even if Link's Awakening DX is strictly superior version of the exact same game, it lacked the punch and newness that the 1993 GB title had. And LA for S (what I call LAHD), it's amazing and I love it to death but it feels quite different from the game boy game. This is how I want to see remakes of other similar game boy titles (The Frog for Whom The Bell Tolls; Zelda Oracle series) but if you don't like it becasue of how different it looks from both the manual/box art of LA and from the tiny sprite art of the game, I get it.
@Strumpan now I see that, having read the rest of the comments. Sorry and thank you!
Link's Awakening was amazing, but better than A Link to the Past? No way!
Well... No. The order is a bit rough. Not surprising, but a bit rough.
My top 3 (not in order) would include:
Majora's Mask
Skyward Sword
Breath of the Wild
Tri Force Heroes also very underrated.
Them's fighting words.
My top 5 (obviously not objective):
1. Majora's Mask
2. Breath of the Wild
3. A Link Between Worlds
4. Ocarina of Time
5. Twilight Princess
A Link to the Past and A Link Between Worlds are great, but I think the best 2D one is Link's Awakening, original or DX. The remake didn't really do it for me - I think it needs d-pad control and the "grid" map system.
Wind Waker is my favourite 3D one as I think it had a magical tone, perfect gameplay and the right balance of linear plot and optional exploration. Ocarina of Time is 2nd, I'd say the 3DS one for now. Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess (GC or Wii U) battle for 3rd place.
If Nintendo would remake Ocarina of Time with visuals as good as Metroid Prime Remastered, that would be one impressive piece of software.
I don't really care where each game falls. Most of the bigguns are special to me for their own reasons, and I'm not going to relitigate the strengths and weaknesses of BotW especially. I love that game.
That said Skyward Sword is just not for me at all, it seems. I keep trying with that game. Bores me to tears.
A Link to the Past should be third. Awakening is great, but ALttP is pure MAGIC.
I loved the open world of BOTW and the crafting mechanism but absolutely hated the fact that they didnt include themed dungeons. I know there were the shrines but the were not anywhere near as good as the full blown dungeons from previous Zelda titles imo. The degradable weapons were not my bag and broke far too quickly. Also the bosses absolutely sucked. I hope the new game has dungeons otherwise it will be a hard pass from me. (ive avoided everything on the game up until now)
Not enough love for A Link Between Worlds and Spirit Tracks. Both are amazing games.
I personally would put the Switch remake of Link's Awakening above the originals, Wind Waker HD above the original, and the 3DS remakes of OoT and MM above the originals.
Sad to see Zelda II rank so low on the list
Having just played it for the first time a couple of weeks ago, Link's Awakening Remake is criminally low on this list.
Breath of the Wild on its throne, where it belongs.
Majora's Mask 3D, The Wind Waker HD, A Link Between Worlds, and A Link to the Past would fill out the rest of my top five.
Hopefully Tears of the Kingdom hits a new series high. Less than two months left!
I don't absolutely agree with this list
@ThainEshKelch that makes sense I suppose
@FleaBag_11 Cheers!
Why are the Skyward Swords so low? HD was so good, and definitely much better than the Wii version.
I didn’t realize until now that SS is so disliked. I didn’t really like the Wii version, but the port was great. Also, why are the originals above the remakes/ports?
@Strumpan um, you mean #8?
tri force heroes. 😔
my wife (then girlfriend) and i were HYPED when this came out, bought (if memory serves) TWO copies so we could play through a 2d zelda TOGETHER(!!!) ....only to find that its a one OR three player game, not a 1-3 player game. 😮💨
i mean seriously who can get the same group of three people together enough to actually play through a game like this? children, i suppose.
ive not seen this requirement ever in a game, before or since.
such a wasted opportunity (and money.)
@JH1022 Link to the Past is nowhere near the best Zelda and it hasn't aged well. Its own sequel does everything better. Link's Awakening is just better in every capacity right down to dungeon design, the overworld, gameplay, characters, story and exploration.
I really wanted to like Skyward Sword, but I just didn’t gel with that one. I might give it another shot, but the intro is so sluggish. You need to caffeinate yourself or your fall asleep wandering around that boring first dungeon.
Top five: 1. Breath of the Wild 2. Link’s Awakening 3. Link to the Past 4. Wind Waker 5. Ocarina
@NotTelevision Yeah Skyward Sword has a very heavy narrative. They went back on that with BOTW.
Not bad!
For me, 1.BotW 2.WW 3.OoA 4.MM 5.OoT
Holy overrated twilight princess
@LikelySatan Same and personally I like even Skyward Sword (finally finished it thanks to the Switch version), but absolutely fair if that one's not for you!
That's a terrible "best of list"!!! Zelda: wand of Gamelon should definitely be #1.
I don’t understand why people love OoT so much. It is not a bad game in the least, but I think it sits somewhere around 5 or 6 to me on a list. I didn’t play it when it came out, but played it about 6 years ago for the first time. I would out BoTW, Links Awakening, the original, and maybe even Skyward Sword above it. Not knocking it, and totally respect people ranking it highly, it’s just interesting to me how I love the series and definitely don’t agree with the majority on this one.
This list is based on audience voting. I'd like to hear from that guy who said that BotW is really a 8/10 game after the honeymoon period. It seems most players rate it as the best Zelda and that can be no less than 10/10.
@JohnnyMind I want to like it. Hope I do some day.
Breath of the Wild is great game no question but its not a great Zelda game by any stretch.
Hyrule Warriors AOC is underrated
Tip three for me would be 1. Ocarina, 2. Wind Waker, 3. Breath of the Wild. After that not sure, one of the 2d ones, maybe link to the past. Ocarina and wind waker are the most magical and have the best ideas in them. Breath of the wild in 3rd for its incredible art style despite fewer great gaming ideas and fewer memorable characters. MM was amazing but a bit gimmicky, twilight princess was really good - a lot better than skyward sword which fell flat.
@Dr_Corndog Yeah they did make one already.
@AstraeaV I think that would be a lot of fun
@NotTelevision
Day 4 of Skyward Sword with no sleep. Soda getting flat. Fi just won't...stop.......talking!!!
@sketchturner
You said: "BotW is great but it doesn't have dozens of memorable moments like OoT, does it? I've completed BotW 4 times and almost nothing stands out in my mind."
Your statement is a bit of a head-scratcher. BotW has tons of memorable moments.
I could go on and on.
I grew up with Ocarina of Time and played it with all vigor when it first released on the N64. Breath of the Wild held just as many memorable moments for me. Probably more, if I'm being real.
I think skyward sword should have been ranked higher because it has great dungeons and a good story the only bad part about it to me is the getting off skyloft
also link crossbow training is the best game ever made
So TOTK is better than BOTW in almost every way, but BOTW tops the rankings, how does that work? Anyway Ocarina is still tops for me.
On my list TOTK made it to nr1 2nd is now ocarina of time, 3rd majoras mask and 4th ia Breath of the wild.
@Gracetrack But non of those are memorable "Zelda" moments and could easily have come from any open world game. Most of the ones you highlighted reminds me of my time playing ESO.
There is no feeling of progression in BotW or TotK compared with okder entries in the series, you get all of the needed tools in the few minutes of the game and the rest of the "game" is opening towers and random NPC fetch quests (like every ubisoft open world game to date).
For me the joy in Zelda games has always been getting a new Item and then figuring out how to use it to beat the dungeon and subsequent boss.
Link's Awakening is an impressive Game Boy game, but vastly overrated. There, I said it.
@Sinton when did you play it? Cause i think that matters.
I’ve played TOTK for 5 hours and I can already say it’s a better game than botw
Link between worlds, link to the past, minish cap, botw and Tears of the Kingdom are my top 5 to play. Loooove them
Nearly finished totk and it's excellent, but can't put my finger on exactly why I still prefer botw over it.
Best: Ocarina of Time, Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess.
@Chaotic_Neutral
"none of those are memorable 'Zelda' moments and could easily have come from any open world game. Most of the ones you highlighted reminds me of my time playing ESO."
1. You can't honestly say that things like your first encounter with a BotW Guardian robot, your first encounter with a Lynel, first time shield-surfing while popping off arrows at enemies, first time encountering a Divine Beast, your first Shrine, your first encounter with the Lord of the Mountain, your first time causing lightning to strike an enemy by using your own equipment as a lightning rod, your first time starting a brush fire and then using the updraft it creates to glide up on your paraglider and bullet-time snipe an enemy with arrows... and so forth... are experiences that "could easily have come from any open world game" prior to BotW. And no, I'm not going to allow you to fallaciously emphasize things which are simply common to video games writ large, such as shooting arrows at things, having dungeon-like structures, puzzle-solving, etc.. A lot of games share base-level ideas and mechanics such as those, but that does not mean they can't/don't implement them in ways that are uniquely their own. Those things I listed about BotW are uniquely BotW, and thus uniquely Zelda.
2. That person’s statement, the one to which I originally replied, made no differentiation between memorable “moments” and memorable “Zelda moments”. He didn’t even so much as imply said distinction. That's because...
3. Making such a distinction is silly. Friend, a memorable moment is a memorable moment, period.
4. When I think of Breath of the Wild, I remember all those moments and more. Therefore, they are “memorable moments” for me.
5. Hard disagree that there isn't a great feeling of progression in BotW. I sensed a great deal of progression during my 200+ hours of playing the game.
6. To your final remark, I’m glad that’s what gives you joy in Zelda games. That and much more gives me joy in Zelda games. BotW was lacking that aspect, but the joy of everything else in it completely washed away any feeling of disappointment I might have had in there being no classically designed dungeons.
Grace and Peace.✌️
I’m actually enjoying TotK perhaps even more than BotW, which is my personal favorite. TotK might end up being my personal #1. Quite impressive after all the Zelda games I’ve played over the years.
I haven't played every Zelda so I can't really vote. But the two that are the most memorable to me, by a large margin, is the first game and The Wind Waker.
Having the Warriors Toei games here doesn't really fit for me.
@Chaotic_Neutral I wholeheartedly agree.
@Friendly It shouldn't matter in a ranking of best games of all time. But I played it six years ago. Played three or four Zelda games that year, and the rest were better.
TOTK has taken my top spot, and not just for Zelda games either. This is what it feels like to rekindle the love of Nintendo magic and a reminder why I always stick with 'em. When Nintendo is "on" there's nothing better, and TOTK has (like when I got my Switch back in 2017) reminded me of what it felt like to just LOVE that magic.
@Sinton it does matter, though, considering this is a user score and a lot of the score is based on nostalgia and impact at the time. Also, did you play link’s awakening as the 3d or 4th in a row that year? The games might to feel a bit sameish after a couple before that.
Having said that: Link’s Awakenings is my first Zelda game ever and i’m still blown away that that fully fledged game fits on a gameboy cartridge and I still love it and replay the game every two years.
Link’s Awakening should not be placed higher than Link to the Past. They are both awesome games but Link to the Past is better.
TotK has the best story out of any Zelda game (so far at least, haven't yet completed it), and it has so much better sidequests compared to BotW.
Otherwise, it's pretty much like BotW, except more complex and with a lot more content. Some could argue it could be even be a bit too complex and overwhelming to its own good, and prefer the more simplistic approach of BotW.
I want to finish TotK 100%, and that does not mean collecting all korok seeds, I just meant doing all the other side adventures/ quests etc., before deciding whether it's better than BotW or not.
Also, I would love to see Majora’s Mask (whichever version, I played the 3ds one) at least make the top five as it is my favorite Zelda game.
How is BOTW top? Tears of the Kingdom is better in every single way and even without that game I wouldn't put BOTW 1st.
My top 3 would be
Ocarina of Time
Tears of The Kingdom
Windwaker
@Il_Nintenditore I agree with you, Ocarina of Time is the literally foundation of how we play 3D action adventure games today. Even the recent God of War games adapted to follow its formula and became a huge success off the back of that
In before ''Your Zelda game is so overrated and my Zelda game is very underrated'' comments
Oh wait... I'm about 100 comments too late...
My God, there is no chance that Link's Awakening is better than A Link to the Past.
@Friendly Even if the score is based on nostalgia, it shouldn't give a game released in 1993 any edge over a game released in 1992 (A Link to the Past), for instance. And no one can convince me that a Game Boy game is better than every single Super Nintendo game.
I don't recall exactly the order, but I'm guessing after A Link to the Past and before Twilight Princess.
@Namco Isn't that the point of a comment section to any «best of» article? What else should we discuss?
My favourite Zelda games are, A Link To The Past, Link's Awakening, Ocarina Of Time, Majoras Mask, Wind Waker, Twillight Princess and Skyward Sword.
I am sure the list will get bigger.
I would absolutely love a remake of a link to the past in the same way they did links awakening…
Day 1 preorder that!
@RetroGames I enjoy them each equally, very fun games.
Only thing sillier than Zelda II being so low is Link between Worlds being so high.
Well, that, and filling this list with spin-offs and remakes. Oh, well.
@Il_Nintenditore
Nah, just the way people go about it... You at least put ''my opinion'' behind well... your opinion. Some comments are just ''This one shouldn't be this high, it's really not as good as you think! Facts!''
Not that I really care, I was just messing around, as I'm sure more users in this comment section are.
I’m sure TotK will get higher as time goes on
@Sinton a link to the past and link’s awakening are very similar mechanics wise. I think what you felt was ‘more of the same’, instead of something refreshing or new. Link’s awakening is my favourite of the two because it was the first zelda for me, the story, music and setting intrigues me way more, it is more condensed, focused and less bloated by a lot of stuff and mechanics and tools you never use. So yeah, to me it deserves a higher mark.
gane ratings have to evolve over time in the era they are ranked..
I don’t understand the adoration for Link’s Awakening. Is it just nostalgia? I’ve played a couple of times (both GB and remake) and it’s just such a weak entry in the series to me. I like the story and concept, but the dungeons and world design are some of the worst in the series to me. Am I missing something? Maybe I just don’t get it.
That aside, LOVING Tears of the kingdom so far.
Zelda on the nes, where it all started, the grandmother of all zelda games... Hard to ignore the absence in the top 5.
I'm glad to see Link's Awakening in the Top 3, it's got one of the best stories, soundtracks, and settings in the series. It's also secretly one of the most influential Zelda games too, LttP may have established the Zelda formula but Awakening refined it in terms of combat, progression, and how dungeons worked. It's the superior game in every way aside from scale.
Twilight Princess was the peak of the TLoZ franchise. It has all the elements that make a Zelda game legendary.
BotW and TotK are great games, but not great Zelda games.
@StarryCiel I disagree on all points. I don't understand how anyone can say the dream story is any good, and it's far from the best the series has to offer. And while it's soundtrack is good for a Game Boy game, I would never listen to those instead of the later games (or even the three first in the series).
How did it improve combat, progression and how dungeons work?
@Sinton LttP's dungeons are very heavy on the combat, and the Boss Key unlocking the dungeon item is something no other game in the series does. Awakening's dungeons strike a better balance between navigation, platforming, puzzle-solving and combat. I also think the overworld is more dense and visually-varied than LttP's Hyrule, and I prefer how you slowly uncover it throughout the game. As for the combat and movement in general, it just feels more fluid in the GB games and Link's sword is a bit less stubby.
I hard disagree on the dream story though, I'd say it's one of the most personal and emotional stories in the series and the way the twist was revealed is incredibly well-done. Link's Awakening is one of my favorite games period, it doesn't matter if it's on a Game Boy or a Switch, 2D or 3D, because I think its design is pretty much perfect.
@StarryCiel I still disagree, but thanks for the thorough explanation.
@StarryCiel And to be clear, I enjoy Link's Awakening for what it is, and it's probably the best Game Boy game made. But to me it's like a concept album that deviates somewhat from my favorite artist's original sound.
Top 5:
1. Majora's Mask
2. Link's Awakening (Switch version)
3. Tears of the Kingdom
4. A Link to the Past
5. Breath of the Wild
TOTK is a far better game than BOTW! It improved everything in marvelous ways! And to me it’s the best game of all time already along with Link to the Past and OOT.
BotW is a Wii U game
Both wind waker versions over Twilight Princess.
BASED.
Great list but I would personally rank 'Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity' a lot higher. Awesome game and I loved being able to play as Zelda (fully powered), Mipha, Revali and Impa and being able to see what parts of Hyrule looked like before they were destroyed.
I would love a sequel set in the changed timeline with the champions still alive or another 'Hyrule Warriors' game that connects onto 'Tears of the Kingdom' in a similar way.
I'm an original Link's Awakening and Majora's Mask fan, but man am I ever smitten with Tears. It will be interesting to see how people look back on it. I just finished a quest that I am not going to spoil, but it was absolutely amazing.
@Debbiee Hyrule Warriors sure is a dope DW mod.
@Sculptor The Legend of Zelda is a Famicom Disk System game...
Too many spin-offs and rereleases! Stick to the mainline!
Haven't looked at the list yet but I'm pretty sure I can take an educated guess on where TOTK falls XD
EDIT: ....well I'll be damned: I actually didn't see that coming 👏
As for my personal favourite, while I haven't played too many Zelda games myself, it's definitely a toss-up between Link to the Past and Link's Awakening: both provide clear advantages over the other that make it pretty difficult to choose between them. LttP has incredibly engaging gameplay between overworld exploration, items and dungeon design, while LA provides an utterly enrapturing story that really made me feel connected to the place I was exploring. As someone who greatly values the role of story in games, LA is my current favourite but both are absolutely fantastic
In my opinion, a link to the past will bever be topped
This list would feel more tidy if you’d bunch together the re-releases, at least in cases where the retouch was absolutely minor. Skyward Sword, Wind Waker, Majora’s Mask, Ocarina and Twilight Princess are almost identical to their first issues. I’d argue that the only remake worthy of a separate entry is Link’s Awakening.
Remasters and sequels that show improvements and address flaws in the the original/predecessor, as stated in this list.
Yet are all ranked lower than the original/predecessor…
…what?
Hard to pick a top 5 anymore lol. Ultimately will probably be BotW, ALBW, AoL, OoT and TotK.
Best Zelda games ever made...
OoT
MM
WW
LttP
@locky-mavo The Majora's Mask remake is inferior. It ruined Zora swimming and the bosses.
@Znake I agree. I love botw, but it’s ludicrous that an improved version of it is lower, but whatever. At least it’s with OoT and Botw.
If "to each their own" was a list. 🤣
Everyone is allowed to have their own opinion. That being said, this list is wrong. Haha!
Pretty good list but all the different versions really clutter it up. Also Link's Awakening DX being below the original doesn't make any sense. I think it would be better if all the versions were grouped to only list the best one.
Ocarina
Majora's Mask
Links Awakening DX
Oracle of Ages & Seasons
Wind Waker
Tears of the Kingdom
Minish Cap
Link to the Past/Link Between Worlds (Too similar, both good)
Twilight Princess
Skyward Sword
Breath of The Wild (Totk did EVERYTHING better)
Spirit Tracks
Phantom Hourglass
Zelda 1
Zelda 2 (only game I don't really consider a real zelda game)
The only Zelda game I've played to completion is Breath of the Wild, and I have yet to find the Open-World game that can make me sing its praises. I hope Tears of the Kingdom will be better, but I'm not going to prioritize getting it due to my experience with Breath of the Wild.
@Znake @Mrkittyhead Tears sacrificed so much of what made BOTW special in service of the Ultrahand mechanic. Puzzles, exploration, combat - all of it got tied to building and tinkering with these pieces and devices. People who like tinkering with that kind of stuff got BOTW+, while the rest of us got a pared down version of the game we love, where everything became infinitely more tedious.
And if you add in the main map being recycled, and the new map additions being a handful of sky islands and the most tedious and dreary slog of an underground world, and you get a lot of people who see TOTK as the lesser version of the game. I 100%ed BOTW and played through it probably a dozen times, while I haven't even finished TOTK.
@Mrkittyhead sometimes less is more
@ThisIsJosh … well said. Completely agree with your take
For me its ocarina of time, then botw, TP, WW, link to the past and lastly links awakening switch version
I feel like we’re getting this list every six months or so.
I'll say it before, and I'll say it again: Twilight Princess is my personal favorite. I find it to be the best of both worlds when it comes to exploration and story. With a huge world full of nooks and crannies to explore, and a story filled to the brim with fun characters and plot twists, it's as if Ocarina of Time and Breath of the Wild/Tears of the Kingdom were merged into one.
It also has a wealth of content that keeps me unable from getting bored. I especially love the minigames. It also has the most robust fishing mechanic I've ever seen in a Zelda game, especially if you play the Wii version (where you can move the Wii Remote and Nunchuk in such a way that it feels like you're actually casting out and reeling in).
I know it gets flak by some people for "being an Ocarina of Time clone," but the way I see it, it took what was great about Ocarina of Time and dialed it up to 11. How anyone can complain about that is frankly beyond me; I can only chalk it up to nostalgia for Ocarina of Time. Don't get me wrong, though: while Ocarina of Time is THE game that made me a gamer for life, I would rather take Twilight Princess any day.
Taking a look at the ratings...it looks like over 1,600 NintendoLife users have played Breath of the Wild but not Ocarina of Time?
@MontyCircus The problem with NL user ratings is, you can only rate a game once you've added it to your game collection on the site. I've played through Ocarina of Time but I've never owned a N64 copy of it, so I've never bothered to add it to my collection in order to rate it here. It would be nice if they allowed us to rate games without this needless extra step.
Putting all the remakes in their own spots instead of just combining them into 1 spot was totally unnecessary. Otherwise, list is for the most part fine outside Wind Waker is way, way, way too high.
The top 4 has my personal top 4 in it
So happy to see BotW at number 1 on this list. It is such a beautiful game. TotK is ok but nowhere near as good.
That Zelda II slander makes me sad.
@ZimmerRemmiz Agreed. The fact any games are above it is a travesty. It's the one game that needs a remake so the horrid hit boxes can be rectified. There's a good game there... but the hit boxes ruin the fun.
@ThainEshKelch Does the NSO version of Ocarina of Time have the blurriness and low draw distance? I haven't played that version a lot.
Tri Force Heroes often gets dissed, but I don't know if I've ever laughed harder when playing a game with randoms.
@Ulysses no clue as I have no intention to pay for NSO. But it would surprise me if it isn’t the same version as the Wii emulation version.
Multiple versions of the same game shouldn't be on this list. Minish Cap and especially Link's awakening are hugely overrated, while the DS games are very underrated.
The switch games are hard to compare to the classic games. It's fun to replay a 20-30 hour game. A 200 hour game not so much.
HaileySheridon wrote:
I didn't know Nintendo had a version of "I only game in 4K" fans.
I thought we were those that value gameplay over graphics.
Oh well. Maybe that would be an interesting poll.
I will never understand why people prefer Spirit Tracks to Phantom Hourglass. I mean, sure, having Link on a train as a conductor is funny, but being literally on rails on the overworld is not fun, the most tedious navigation in any Zelda game ever. Just novelty. Not that I hate either of them, I think they are solid.
Anyway, Hyrule Warriors does not belong on this list, it should be on Warriors/Musou lists, not on Zelda games lists.
Very interesting with a list where the remakes and remasters was included as separate entries and allowed the original versions of the game to go up against them. Too often the people who makes these kinds of lists assume that throwing old visuals, sound and game mechanics in the bin and replacing them with what’s currently in vogue, automatically makes a game better.
I’m also very happy to see the original version of Link’s Awakening rank so high and above the remake and DX version. While both of those are good as well, the original game in monochrome looks much better than the DX version with its garish colors. The fact that it also adds some overpowered items in the end, doesn’t help it's case either.
The later remake is cool, but it changes the feeling of the game a lot.
The ability to appreciate the visuals of original Gameboy games is probably an acquired taste for those who didn’t play the system when it was new. But if you can appreciate the stylished pixel look of NES games and also the look of black and white movies, it is in many ways like a mix of those two. For people not playing on original hardware, using Retroarch with one of the filters makes it look almost exactly like a real Gameboy. And in fact even better, since you can turn of the blur, which you can’t do on the real hardware. I would recommend playing Gameboy games in monochrome and not with any of those palettes that came with the Super Gameboy or Gameboy Color, as those are extremely garish.
@FlyingDunsparce
"Also Link's Awakening DX being below the original doesn't make any sense."
I disagree on that. The garish colors in the DX version makes it much less enjoyable to me. And the fact that you get some overpowered items in the end doesn't help its case either. The original is "the definitive" version.
You seem to assume that colors automatically makes something better, but that isn't necessarily the case. Just think about black and white photographs and movies, which while they were a product of the technical limitations of their time, evolved to become a style that is still appreciated by many, despite those limitations not existing anymore.
The fact that the original Link's Awakening was voted above the DX version here should serve as a proof for you that what is the "definitive version" is something which people have differing opinions about.
I really appreciate that this list included all the original versions of the games, instead of automatically assuming that chimeras of old and new are automatically better than well-crafted original games.
For a while now the idea that older styles of artwork, sound and mechanics are without value and better thrown in the garbage can, as long as they can be replaced with what is currently in vouge, has been the most popular line of thought. But I think this is about to change and that as the medium of videogames gains more respect and status, the respect for the finer details and history of it will improve as well. Like what has happened with other mediums.
@XCWarrior
I think it was a good idea to have remakes and remasters as their own entries. I hope more lists will use this approach. Too often it is automatically assumed that a newer version is better if it doesn't screw things up, which I don't agree with. And the fact that the original games in many cases were voted above the remakes/remasters here, seems to suggest that it is not an uncommon opinion.
How are the Wii U HD ports ranking lower than the originals - not only do they have much improved visuals - they make gameplay and enjoyment improvements..likewise the 2 Switch remasters (Skyw Sw and Links A) are much better games than the originals
@Mattock1987 never played Skywards Switch port, did you? Completely fixed the controls, camera, and Fis interruptions.
I honestly can't complain after seeing Phantom Hourglass (the lowest non multiplayer mainline game on this list) with a score of 8.1. With that said:
Awakening (any version) and Minish over Past, and
Majora and Skyward (HD) over Ocarina and Breath
Spirit Tracks is super nostalgic for me, although Majora’s Mask just gave me way too much anxiety lol
Me opens door to someone's house in LTTP. Person calls guard for no reason. Watch out mate. I have master sword! CYA CHUM
It's Ganondorf. "SCRAP!!!"
Also I can't wait until echoes of wisdom comes out. It's basically LTTP + Link's awakening + Wisdom prevails (super smash bros classic mode for Zelda.) Also add in a touch of OoT because little fairy companion.
@Perpetual_Change I can understand this, but my one pet peeve with Game Boy games was the lack of distinct color. I will say, though, that DK94 actually looks great on a GBA.
And yeah, LA2019 is a different experience. Still my preferred version, but different enough to where I can justify myself playing the DX version. They're just two ways of playing my 2nd favorite game of all time (Mario Galaxy #1 forever and always).
@Perpetual_Change my honest opinion:
Links Awakening and Wind Waker: doesn't matter. Both (or all) versions are great.
Majora and Four Swords: stick to the original:
LTTP and Twilight: the newer version is the same but with more.
Ocarina and Skyward: stick to the rerelease.
22 out of 34 in a consistent series ain't bad.
But why is the Wii version of Skyward still higher than the Switch version? The Switch version is INFINITELY better.
As a super old gamer, no one ever seems to mention or remember that the OG Zelda on NES was the first NES game to have a built-in save file feature. Previously, you had to write down these obnoxiously long codes to go back to your save point. And if you got one character wrong, you were screwed and had to start over again.
@ShaneReactions as a 41 year old who has never played the OG Zelda i really need to change this.
@ShaneReactions I'm 19 and have known this for at least five or six years. I'm a history geek, after all.
Hello lovely readers. Just a note that we’ve overhauled the format on this list — feel free to drop any feedback regarding the changes here.
So far I approve! All on one page! Table of contents at top to jump to sections. Well done, @dartmonkey!
I haven't liked when lists/rankings span across 3+ pages. I'm quite pleased with this.
@ShaneReactions And those save batteries last forever too. I had a copy of the game that still had my save file all the way up until I sold my NES stuff several years ago. Save file still around after 22 years. No battery lasts that long these days.
@linkypoo I am a Link’s Crossbow Training stan. 😊
@mjharper Ah yes, the long lasting and wonderfully toxic nickel-cadmium batteries 😆
Not a huge fan of the rankings on this list, but hey, it's Zelda and most fans disagree on the series rankings.
Minish Cap, Echoes of Wisdom, Oracle of Seasons, Wind Waker, and Spirit Tracks should be much higher. Each one encapsulates the series in its utmost brilliance.
I wanted to be upset about how low Echoes of Wisdom is but then I saw all the games in front of it and realized for the hundredth time that this is just really an amazing series. But yeah Echoes is great, better than Minish at least if I'm going to follow through with my initial plan to protest.
I would have put EoW before SS.
SS wasn't a good game, but at least it had fun dungeon. Like I always describe SS, it has one of the best dungeon design, but the absolute worst filler (in between dungeons). EoW has Bad dungeons, bad fillers. It's just fun to explore... that's all.
@poudigne I just did the dungeon in the desert and thought it was really good? 2D will obviously feel a little less epic than 3D but I don't feel like it's any worse than prior 2D Zeldas at the very least.
@SpaceboyScreams Dungeons are linear, unchallenging, no puzzles. IMO
Top 5 IMO in no particular order:
So happy to see BotW on top. A good reminder to give it some extra points. Despite the fact that there are so many amazing games in this series (I'm looking at you Link's Awakening DX), it is my favourite.
Still at the beginning of EoW though, so we'll see were it will rank. Probably not among the top 3, but I'm having a good time!
I feel like the first half of EoW was more enjoyable than the second half, mainly due to how pointless a lot of quests and chests ended up feeling when all I get from them are ingredients for smoothies or rupees. If you're going to give the player more to do, you need to make sure that they are properly rewarded for their efforts, and I don't feel like Echoes of Wisdom does that.
@axelhander "well, excuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu. . ."
I knew TotK wouldn’t stand at all… not even two years and it’s already at #4 … it will continue to go down. It’s honeymoon phase is over
@KayFiOS It's even worse because what you can buy for rupees is almost exclusively useless and not worth it. And swapping equipped accessory is unnecessarily tedious to boot — first select the current accessory to unequip it before you can equip another, instead of just swapping — so even if you do spend rupees on, say, a very slight climbing boost accessory, might as well just drink a smoothie when the time comes. Not that I ever needed it anyway.
@KayFiOS I agree, but we have TotK and BotW to thank for that terrible game design. Hey there’s a chest over there… (spends 40 minutes trying to reach it) … ufff I hope it’s something good for my efforts …. (Gets 5 common crafting materials) … FFFF!!!!
You can thank the cooking and crafting in your Zelda games 🙄
I only started getting into Zelda games with the 3DS so I can't comment on the earlier games, but my top 5 so far would be BoTW, Tears of the Kingdom and Wind Waker HD, OOT and Skyward Sword.
Y’all let me play it first before you start ranking!
Also how the Farore is MM so low?!
@Ryu_Niiyama As much as I care to gripe, I saw MM at that position and questioned my faith in humanity yet again.
I bet the top 3 of BOTW, Ocarina of Time, and Link to the Past, will be top 3 in perpetuity. Looking forward to someone quoting this comment in 20 years and saying "you were wrong".
@Nancyboy I am probably gonna get burnt to death for this, but MM put pressure back into LoZ after OoT removed it. If you play LttP, due to the tech at the time there was a decent amount of stuff trying to kill you, like every screen that wasn’t kakariko (I don’t count the snitches). Not enough to make the game stressful but enough to make dungeons (and the overworld) feel dangerous on top of the puzzle aspect.
OoT couldn’t do that or risk the game slowing down to a slide show (or gamers getting overwhelmed) so the focus was more on the dungeon was the enemy. You had little zones that you cleared but honestly for somebody that was actively being hunted you had lots of zones of relative safety (peahats suck but are zoning gates really, but poes were just mcguffins not enemies) both in dungeons and outside them. MM thanks to both the expansion pack and this being the second outing (yay experience) was a bit more enemy filled. It still was about traversal and using the 3D space to figure out puzzles but the dungeons felt dangerous rather than just a puzzle to beat with a boss at the end of it.
As a kid I hated that MM had less dungeons but looking back I feel like OoT could have dropped at least two (no not the water temple). Plus the time mechanic allowed the story to be padded out with less work. (As everyone had a set schedule independent of the player. ) I would love a new Majora type game. But I don’t think it would go down well with others.
I agree with the top 3.
I think TOTK just didnt offer anything new and was largely a re-skin with a game breaking mechanic.
I would place Echoes much higher. It's a bit odd to say its one of the best top down in the series but then put it behind practically every other top down game in the series.
I would also place Twilight Princess higher. It was dark and mature. And had the best supporting character. The music was also some of the best.
I think Majora's Mask is overrated. It became a cult classic. And was a remarkable feat that it was delivered in a year. But it was largely experimental and more of a spin off.
Yikes.
Maybe I should consider returning my unopened copy since I won’t have time to play it for a while.
The N64 Zeldas, and twilight princess, are highly overrated. And breath of the wild and tears of the kingdom are barely Zelda games.
But then I guess that would make a short list.
Sadly for me, Echoes is certainly one of the weaker entries and even amongst the top down games it's not amongst the best. The echo mechanic really needed a bit more thought in how it's implemented as I feel I spend more time navigating a very long bar than actually playing the game at times. Plus limiting what are essentially better controls with the Link form, is just poor game design as far as I'm concerned.
Ocarina and Wind Waker are still my favourites, with A Link to the Past, Minish Cap and Zelda 2 ranking highly
Kidfunkadelic83 wrote:
I would argue that Super Mario Bros. was the best game ever made when it was released in 1985. And The Legend of Zelda was the best game every made when it was released the next year (in Japan).
Don't be shy to hit online guides though. Secrets were not made obvious in game design back then.
Burning. Every. Bush. is quite tedious now in modern times.
Never understood why MM3D was rated so highly on this list. It's not a good remake and removes a lot of the good stuff from the original.
I don't know why the EoW review gave glowing praise and claimed it stood tall among the series' best 2D entries like LA and LttP, but then the placement on this list puts it behind most of the 2D games and even near the bottom...
@Oracles_fanboi The list is based on Nintendo Life's user scores.
@PikaPhantom I see, my mistake.
People really shouldn't be giving scores without playing the games... It doesn't do any good.
As much as I liked that game, Echoes of Wisdom is a way better game than A Link Between Worlds, for example.
The list really shouldn't be bloated with remakes and ports separately. Can't you just use / / instead?
@the_beaver I disagree. Link Between Worlds was a clever game with a really well implemented mechanic and strong overworld.
Echoes feels really shallow and uninspired by comparison. It plays way too safe. It's far, far too easy. The dungeons are so linear and the puzzles too simple. The still worlds are too repetitive.
Exploring the overworld and climbing over trees using a "bed staircase" was fun the 1st time. Absolute chore every other time - and we're talking 100s of times...
The game is missing Nintendo's usual high level of polish too. Things like... when you create a new Smoothie variety it doesn't tell you it's "New" on the picture of the smoothie - just one random example to highlight the point.
Overall Echoes is comfortably one of the worst Zelda games I've played. I think the fact it ranks below the games that it clearly draws inspiration from (LA, Oracles, TP) sums it up perfectly.
Don't mistake the above for me saying its a bad game by the way. I've enjoyed the game a lot. Its just nowhere near the pinnacle of Zelda games. The bar is exceptionally high - to place 22nd with a score of 8.5 says a lot!
@axelhander Zelda II is criminally under rated, Its a pain on the backside admittedly due to sending you back to start after death, but other than that it is a damn fine Zelda game that is so full of character. Superb combat, great atmosphere, an enjoyable but not complex levelling system and great enemy design. The temple/dungeons feel like really dangerous places too. I would love to see Nintendo return to a style like this.
EoW a loved to begin with, but its just tiring, I struggled to finish it. Its a good game, its just not a good Zelda game, ironically enough given the staring role. As far as top down Zelda goes, Minish Cap is still my favourite. That game has a wonderful joy and sense of wonder to it, and the pixel art is gorgeous at times, especially when shrunk. Given how much more powerful consoles are, I'd love to see a return to pixel top down Zelda, with the most stunning pixel art ever done by Nintendo, we could easily be looking at the best looking Zelda game, whether being compared to 2D or 3D, if done right.
@the_beaver You are objectively incorrect.
@axelhander All right, sir.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...